11009 Allisonville Rd
Fishers, IN 46038
Find us on Yelp & Facebook
(317) 863-8686
Introducing Made-to-Order Hot Cake Donut Holes tossed in your choice of toppings! Available daily 7-9 Tues-Fri and 8-10 Saturday.
~ Join us for hot breakfast sandwiches Saturday Mornings 8a - 11a
PRODUCTS
At Mandy's Bake Shop, we strive to fulfill our customer's needs with a wide variety of made from scratch baked goods. This page highlights our standard products but we welcome the opportunity to fill custom orders for products not listed.
Beverages
We are proud to serve local coffee from Noble Coffee & Tea Company (Noblesville) and offer a selection of flavors. Your cup of coffee is fresh brewed when ordered. The beans are ground and the coffee is french pressed to offer the freshest cup of coffee. Our fruit smoothies are hand-made with yogurt, milk, and your choice of real fruit.
​
Coffee
Fruit Smoothies
Hot Tea
Orange Juice
Pop
​
Cake Donut Holes
Cake donut holes made to order and served to you hot and fresh. They are available from 7am - 9am Tuesday through Friday and 8am to 11am on Saturdays. Choice of toppings include:
​
Cinnamon & Sugar
Powdered Sugar
​
Hot Breakfast Sandwiches
Available Saturday mornings from 8am to 11am only. Bacon or sausage, eggs, and cheese on your choice of a biscut or croissant. Eggs, bacon, sausage, and biscuits are available a la carte.
​
​
Pies
Choose from a variety of our pies with light, flaky crusts. Purchase by the slice or whole pie:
Apple
Dutch Apple
Cherry
Blueberry
Peach
Pumpkin (seasonal)
Sugar Cream
Chocolate Cream
Banana Cream
and others
​
Cakes & Cupcakes
Customize your cake or cupcake order with a variety of cake, icing, or filling flavors. Choose from the classic (and delicious) buttercream filling or get creative and add a fruit or Pastry Cream filling.
Suggest a design or theme to match the occassion and we will decorate and personalize to suit your needs.
Brownies
Rich and moist fudge brownies. Available flavors and toppings vary and include plain, peanut butter cup, caramel swirl, and turtle
Pastries
Cinnamon Rolls and Pecan Sticky Buns. Selection varies daily.
Muffins & Quickbreads
Muffins & quickbreads (yeastless breads) are both versatile and delicious. Flavors vary each day and include blueberry, lemon poppyseed, banana nut, pumpkin, or zucchini. Or listen to your gut and request your own custom order creation!
Other Baked Goods
We offer a variety of other decadent baked goods. As always, these products can be customized with many combinations of flavors:
Cookies
Truffles
Caramels
Brittle
Dumpcakes
Don't see a product listed? Just visit our "Contact/Order" page and let us know your needs.